Status Check on Medical ID Theft: Going Up
Security research firm Ponemon Institute estimates that 1.84 million adult-aged Americans have experienced medical identity theft, with 313,000 becoming victims during the past year. That's a 19 percent increase compared with a 2012 Ponemon estimate of 1.52 million who have in recent years been victimized by medical identity theft, based on an annual survey conducted each March and April. This year, the firm surveyed 788 adults who self-reported themselves or their families experiencing medical identity theft. Ponemon concludes that many cases of theft are easily preventable and victims can incur significant out-of-pocket costs. Here is a look at results of the survey, which the Medical Identity Fraud Alliance and ID Experts sponsored.
Education Needed

Being or knowing victims of medical identity theft, many respondents understand what the ramifications can be. But half of respondents were not aware that identity theft can result in unsafe care because of inaccuracies in their permanent medical records, or that insurance premiums can increase because of those inaccuracies. And because many dont experience ramifications, half of those surveyed failed to take steps, such as reviewing explanation of benefits and medical records, to protect themselves from future theft.
Finding Out

Respondents reported a variety of ways they learned of becoming victims of medical identity theft. These include finding mistakes in health records, errors in explanation of benefits, errors posted by providers to invoices, a collection letter, being informed by a provider, an adverse entry on a credit report, or a data breach notification. Once respondents knew of the theft, 56 percent lost trust or confidence in their provider.
Expensive Lesson

While 64 percent of respondents did not incur out-of-pocket costs following medical identity theft, the 36 percent who did really felt it in the wallet. These victims paid an average of $18,660 for identity protection, credit reporting and legal counsel; medical services and medications because of a lapse in insurance coverage; and reimbursements to health care providers or insurers for services given to imposters.
An Ounce of Prevention

Extrapolating survey results, Ponemon estimates a total out-of-pocket cost for all victims of identity medical theft in the United States of more than $12.3 billion. But many of the cases are preventable. Thirty percent of respondents knowingly shared their insurance card or other personal identification with someone they knew. Another 28 percent reported that a member of the family took their personal information without consent. Of those who share their information, 58 percent are female. Of those who do not share their information the ratio is almost even: 48 percent female and 52 percent male. Average household income for those who do not share is considerably higher than those who share.
Taking Charge

While 78 percent of respondents acknowledged the importance of directly controlling medical records, 56 percent of them dont check their records to ensure accuracy. They either dont know how to check the records or trust the provider to be accurate. Actions to take to ward off medical identity theft, Ponemon advises, include reviewing explanation of benefits and medical records, monitoring credit reports, better securing of personal credentials, shredding confidential documents, contracting with an identity protection services firm, seeking providers with better privacy/security practices and avoiding Internet transactions.
Next Steps

Ponemon concludes: Individuals, healthcare and government working together can reduce the risk of medical identity theft. Individuals need to be aware of the negative consequences of sharing their credentials. Healthcare organizations and government must improve their authentication procedures to insure imposters are not obtaining medical services and products.
For a copy of the report, 2013 Survey on Medical Identity Theft, click here.