Profiling HIE Vendors in a Rapidly Evolving Market
New care and payment models are compelling health information exchange vendors to rapidly move from a current HIE 1.0 level of capabilities to an emerging HIE 2.0 level that supports shared payment risk and patient/population health management. A new report from Chilmark Research analyzes where the HIE market is, its leaders, successes and challenges, and where it is quickly going.
Bigger, Faster, Stronger

Existing HIEs offer provider-to-provider messages containing subsets of medical records, whereas HIE 2.0 will provide richer information and more functionality to support collaboration across venues and fill functional gaps. HIE 2.0 applications will be knit together by comprehensive notification services that deliver the right information to the right clinician at the right time on the device or in the clinical application of their choice, says Brian Murphy, lead analyst for the report. No vendor is there yet, but several are aggressively moving to HIE 2.0 capabilities, while many others lag behind.
Provider-Payer Realignment

One, somewhat surprising finding in this years report is the lack of attention most HIE vendors are paying to provider-payer realignment, report authors contend. This is a missed opportunity as new payment models are forcing providers to become more actuarial.
Some providers are partnering with payers, others are acquiring smaller payer organizations and likewise, payers are acquiring providers. Analytics based on HIE-sourced data is still primitive, along with nascent efforts to support population health management, clinical quality and public health reporting, all critical needs in this realignment.
Finding Real Interoperability

The barriers to interoperability remain formidable, Chilmark Research believes. Among others, they include: Matching patients to records (A national patient identifier wont happen and better cross-enterprise master patient indexes are needed); Privacy and consent (A tangle of state and federal rules can limit access to patient data); EHR availability (Not present in all care venues and plenty of paper remains, and many ancillary providers still lack EHR access); and Standards (Plenty of them but a lack of standards-adherent technology.)
Vendor Leaders Tier One

Medicity made large enterprise market gains in 2012 and maintains a strong position in public markets. Orion Health has a strong presence in the public market and is growing in the enterprise market, but lacks big footprint clients. RelayHealth had large gains in the enterprise market last year and its leadership in the Commonwell Health Alliance for vendor interoperability may help accelerate growth.
Vendor Leaders Tier Two

Cerner and partner Certify Data Systems, which Humana owns, have the strongest presence in the enterprise market, but most of CDS installs are in Cerners client base. Allscripts buy of dbMotion will drive further growth, but likely to be less appealing outside the Allscripts client base. InterSystems has re-committed to the HIE market with very capable technology.
Vendor Leaders Tier Three

CareEvolution has a good technology stake and best in market analytics, and is gaining traction despite minimal marketing. OptumInsight (Axolotol) is struggling in the market; its vision is good but execution needs to improve. Surescripts acquisition of Kryptiq gives the HIE vendor a national footprint with the e-prescribing network, and its partnership with Epic and others could accelerate growth.
HIE 1.0: Where We are Today

Functions making good progress: Orders and results, clinician messaging and portal access. Functions making fair progress: Personal health record (HIE vendor interest lags) and lightweight EHRs (meaningful use demands more comprehensive EHRs). Functions making limited progress: EHR access (particularly limited integration to EHR workflow), patient engagement (care coordination lags), clinical quality reporting (vendors appear uninterested) and analytics (some are targeting while some will let others do it). Functions making poor progress: notifications and alerts that often arent relevant; record query across networks is very limited and portal-based; and clinician alignment, of which HIE vendors have extremely limited functionality.
The Promise of HIE 2.0, Part I

Enhanced or new capabilities necessary to support new treatment and payment models include: Exchange Mechanism: query-based exchange and directed exchange. Orders/Results: directed or query for results with the result integrated into the source EHR. Electronic Prescribing: patient engagement and cross-venue medications reconciliation. Personal Health Record: Higher developed patient portals and Blue Button capabilities. Clinical Quality Reporting: Automated process for report submission to public health agencies and payers, with metrics to encourage physician alignment. Notifications and Alerts: Publish/subscribe with delivery to patient and provider on device choice or patients repository of choice. Clinician Access: Predominately embedded in the EHR workflow.
The Promise of HIE 2.0, Part II

Medication Reconciliation: Cross enterprise integration and propagation of medications-related charges. Referrals Management: Closed-loop, cross-enterprise workflow support. Care Plans: Cross-enterprise virtual team using a single care planning workflow with underlying clinical and administrative data. Reporting & Registries: Comprehensive automated reporting to payers and public health agencies. Population Health Management: Robust data and analysis tools for risk-based health care organizations. Analytics: Cross-enterprise supporting population health and clinician alignment. Data Sources: Combined payer and provider data for risk management and care coordination.
Profiling the Vendors

The report includes comprehensive profiles on the strengths, challenges and market presence of 19 vendors, although others also are mentioned. The profiled companies are 4medica, Alere ACS, Caradigm, CareEvolution, Cerner, Certify Data Systems, Covisint, dbMotion, GSI Health, Harris Healthcare, Health Unity, ICA, InterSystems, Medicity, MobileMD, OptumInsight, Orion Health, RelayHealth and Surescripts Kryptiq. The 111-page report, 2013 HIE Market Report: Analysis and Trends, is available for $4,500 at chilmarkresearch.com/chilmark_report/2013-hie-market-trends-report/.