Private HIEs: The Pros and Cons
Private HIEs: Pros and Cons
A feature in the upcoming March edition of HDM examines the pros and cons of private health information exchanges. Following are a few of the issues that face private exchanges.
A Growth Industry

By most counts, private health information exchanges are booming. Large integrated health systems are making these investments to connect to physicians and other entities like long-term care organizations, says Ralph Wakerly, an I.T. consultant.
The last year has seen a dramatic rise in the number of hospital-driven HIEs, according to Mark Allphin, research director at KLAS, Orem, Utah. KLAS defines private HIE as one not accepting government funding. Its most recent analysis, from late 2011, reveals some 160 private HIEs were live compared with 67 public exchanges.
What is a Private HIE?

Definitions vary. Sometimes called enterprise HIEs, the hallmark of the private HIE is ownership by a hospital or health system, which bears its cost, controls its governance, and determines its membership. In contrast, stateor regional or community--HIEs have open memberships and typically received funding from government agencies.
CMS, for example, has designated a number of HIEs as statewide exchanges and provided a total of $547 million for their development.
Speed Advantage Goes to Private HIEs

Enterprise HIE advantage #1Speed. Hospitals launching a private HIE say they can get the effort moving much more quickly than they could by participating in a regional data exchange. The public HIE operates in a wildly diverse environment, says John Norenberg, vice president, physician services, for Advocate Health Care, a Chicago-area health system building a private exchange. And the first thing you do in a diverse environment is move to the lowest common denominator, a thin veneer of data everyone can initially agree on.
Direct Connections

Another advantage for enterprise HIEs is the ability to connect to physicians directly. By targeting local physicians, the private HIE helps the hospital strengthen its referral base and prepare for accountable care payment models.
Overall market place consolidation is driving the growth of enterprise HIEs, says Mike Mytych, president and founder, Health Information Consulting, Menomonee Falls, Wisc. Hospitals are acquiring other hospitals and are acquiring physician practices, many with EHRs, he says. These private organizations need a virtual EHR and they are looking to their own HIE to create one.
Wheres that Patient?

Conversely, a disadvantage for enterprise HIEs can be serving patients. Although a hospital may successfully tether physicians, the private data exchange falls short when it comes to tracking patients. They may seek care beyond the health system. Major health systems have [created enterprise HIEs] to keep patients wedded to them, says Laura Kolkman, R.N., founder and president of Mosaica Partners, a Tampa Bay-based consulting firm which specializes in advising data exchanges. Thats the wrong goal.
Sticker Shock

Another drawback for enterprise HIEs is cost. Building the private exchange is a costly endeavor. The community data exchange realizes economies of scale by sharing the expense of interfaces among a wide pool. In addition, the community exchange does the heavy lifting of gathering consent forms and setting policy, a task which can prove challenging for individual hospitals.
A Big HIE Tent?

Why the lure? Hospitals building private HIEs are concerned about the longevity of publicly funded data exchanges. And even proponents of community-oriented exchanges say they can only rely temporarily on grant money.
Are both models needed? Citing the vast number of HIEs now operating (over 200 by several estimates), many experts predict a shake-out is forthcoming. Nonetheless, they see a role for both the private exchange (which can better facilitate point-to-point transactions, such as lab ordering) and community exchanges (which are better positioned to deliver public health services, such as disease surveillance).