New HHS Meaningful Use Security Audits: What You Need to Know

Most providers participating in the electronic health records meaningful use program know that the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services conducts audits to verify that those attesting for meaningful use actually have met all of the requirements. But a separate and tougher MU audit program—focus

Author
HDM Staff
Save
Share

    New HHS Meaningful Use Security Audits: What You Need to Know

    Most providers participating in the electronic health records meaningful use program know that the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services conducts audits to verify that those attesting for meaningful use actually have met all of the requirements. But a separate and tougher MU audit program—focused on the security of protected health information with a strong focus on the EHR—is ramping up. (Photo: Fotolia)


    Mixed Message

    The HHS Office of Inspector General has started its own audit program, the scale of which OIG still hasn’t announced. Elana Zana, an attorney at the Ogden Murphy Wallace law firm in Seattle, knows of three such audits. At a HIMSS15 presentation, she tried reassuring a large audience that, “Really these audits are not so scary.” But they are comprehensive and will take considerable resources to handle. “This is not someone you want to show up at your door,” she cautioned. (Photo: Fotolia)


    Apples and Oranges

    If CMS completes a meaningful use audit and concludes that a provider did not attest in good faith for one or more reasons, it will withhold payment or demand repayment of incentive payments. On the other hand, OIG is focused on the security requirements of meaningful use; it wants to know if an organization’s meaningful use program adequately complies with HIPAA and sufficiently protects ePHI. If it doesn’t, that could constitute fraud. (Photo: Fotolia)


    Getting Picked

    Following receipt of an audit notification letter, which will come to the top leader of an organization, several auditors from OIG will show up, take over a conference room, review ePHI protection procedures over several years through multiple meaningful use stages, and will stay on-and-off for two or three weeks. (Photo: Fotolia)


    Risk Analysis

    Auditors will focus on the comprehensiveness of the organization’s risk analysis and subsequent remediation of deficiencies and contingency plans for protecting ePHI in emergency situations. They then will compare an organization’s performance with government and industry best practices, Zana said. (Photo: Fotolia)


    Looking for Security Holes

    While CMS meaningful use audits focus on making sure attestations for achieving meaningful use are legitimate, the OIG audit looks at the security profile of the EHR and connected networks, business associates, including cloud services The OIG audit considers additional protections that CMS has not required, such as turning on and using audit review logs in the EHR.

    Also, Zana noted, if an organization has a contract with an EHR vendor to host the system, OIG will want to know if the vendor is actually doing the hosting or if it has contracted with an outside cloud service, and the provider must know the name of the cloud service. (Photo: Fotolia)


    Deep Dive

    OIG auditors are individuals that understand security and will take deep dives into 17 specific areas of interest. During the HIMSS presentation, attorney David Schoolcraft of the Ogden Murphy Wallace law firm listed many of them:

    Risk assessment audits and reports, EHR security plan, organizational chart, network diagram, EHR web sites and patient portals, policies and procedures, system inventory, tools to perform vulnerability scans, central log and event reports, EHR system users, and contractors supporting the EHR and network perimeter devices. (Photo: Fotolia)


    Interviews

    Importantly, OIG will want to talk to the person primarily responsible for each of the 17 areas of interest to address how well policies and procedures are followed. Auditors will want descriptions of where ePHI is stored in the organization and outside of it. “If you don’t have business associate agreements, that will be a problem, and that will be exposed,” Schoolcraft said. Be prepared to provide policies covering risk assessments, encryption, a plan of action including milestones/corrections of deficiencies, incident response, patch management, access controls, audit logging and/or audit controls. (Photo: Fotolia)


    Negotiate

    When OIG asks for an EHR or network diagram, try to avoid just giving it to them; ask if they must have an actual copy or will negotiate how to make the necessary information available but minimize dissemination, Schoolcraft advised. “You don’t want to have your network details floating around somewhere inside the government.” (Photo: Fotolia)


    Readiness Plan

    Developing an Audit Readiness Plan, with tasks to complete before and after an audit notification letter arrives. Having a plan will considerably ease the task, according to Zana and Schoolcraft. Tips for the plan include:

    Store screenshots, numerators, denominators and other collected meaningful use data used for attestation for at least three years. Evaluate vendors to determine the extent to which they are following contract terms. Identify the team that will respond to an upcoming audit. Gather information consistent with the OIG audit questionnaire that will come with the notification letter. Conduct a mock audit to assess readiness. (Photo: Fotolia)


    Light at the End of the Tunnel

    It is normal to dread an upcoming audit, but clients who have gone through the process say the audit was probably cheaper than hiring a company to analyze the organization’s security profile, Schoolcraft said. And lawsuits filed after a breach are a lot worse than an audit. “Yes, this is scary stuff, but it’s also healthy stuff,” he noted. “I would much rather go through this process with OIG than with plaintiffs’ lawyers.” (Photo: Fotolia)