ICD-10: Here Comes Trouble

Top ICD-10 fear factors facing the industry.

Author
HDM Staff
Save
Share

    ICD-10: Here Comes Trouble

    The deadline for the industry-wide transition is still nearly two years away, but experts say there’s plenty to be worried about. Following is a list of top ICD-10 fear factors, which are reported on in detail in HDM’s December edition.


    Fear Factor #1: Industry Preparation

    WEDI, which promotes electronic data exchange and standards, has conducted five national surveys since late 2009. According to the data, some two-thirds of payer and provider respondents have not even completed a full impact assessment—the first, critical step toward ICD-10 remediation.

    Those organizations that have completed their impact assessment often get a jolt : On the payer side, UnitedHealth Group has inventoried over 700 systems affected by ICD-10, including “claims platforms, processing applications and decision support tools,” says Ross Lippincott, vice president, 5010 and ICD-10 programs.


    Fear Factor #2: Vendor Readiness

    Even homegrown systems will need modification to support ICD-10 codes, which require up to seven alphanumeric characters compared with as few as three in ICD-9. The number of diagnosis codes will expand from 13,000 to 68,000, with procedure codes ballooning from 3,000 to 87,000, according to the Chicago-based American Medical Association.

    Wendy Wittington, M.D., chief medical officer at Anthelio Healthcare Solutions, which provides outsourced labor to I.T. departments, says that EHRs based on ICD-9 will need a switch-out. “I don’t have complete confidence in all the vendors that it will be smooth. There may be a couple that will get it right. But since so much in our transition to the EHR hasn’t been smooth, it’s hard to have faith.”


    Fear Factor #3: ‘Shadow’ Systems

    A “complete” systems inventory is difficult to achieve, particularly in a research hospital setting where departments may have deployed systems and created databases away from the watchful eye of the I.T. department.

    Partners HealthCare, a Boston-area delivery system with 12 hospitals, completed its core inventory in 2009, says Bernice von Saleski, director of PHS coding and member of the Partners 5010/ICD-10 steering committee. “We are mainly worried about homegrown systems. We have a lot of intelligent doctors who may have created data bases with I-9 and who are not aware of I-10.”


    Fear Factor #4: Productivity Hit

    A given in the industry is that a steep drop in work output will occur—particularly on the part of coders who will be called on to interpret physician documentation and apply the appropriate codes under ICD-10. And physicians too will be called on to perhaps document with even greater specificity than they do now.

    Shiny George, director of HIM informatics at University of Pennsylvania Health System, is preparing for the hit by building relationships with outsourced coding vendor companies. “Finding good coders when I-10 comes will be a challenge,” she says. “One of my own staff says she may retire. Even with ICD-9 it’s hard to find good coders.”


    Fear Factor #5: Dual Processing

    ICD-10 takes effect in October 2013. But for a period of time after, both ICD-9 and ICD-10 will be in play. That’s because claims will be based on the date of service, not the date of transmission.

    So claims for services performed before the cut-off, but dispatched after it, would still go out in I-9. And adjudication of those services would also be affected in a similar fashion.


    Fear Factor #6: Testing

    Exactly how that interplay between providers and payers takes place is anybody’s guess. The correct use of ICD-10 will, by its very nature, be difficult to assess—at least from the information processing point of view.

    If you don’t have the right monitoring in place, you won’t be able to see something is wrong until further down the road. Thus, programming, coding or mapping errors could result in claims landing in an inappropriate payment grouping, thus resulting in incorrect reimbursement.


    Fear Factor #7: Cash Flow Hit

    All the uncertainty around ICD-10 points in one direction: a likely disruption in cash flow. And providers need to be preparing now for it.

    Wittington, the physician, notes the increased granularity of ICD-10 will not result in greater reimbursement. “Payers will react,” she says, suggesting that health plans could in fact use the new specificity to require even greater justification for payment.


    Fear Factor #8: Undermined Analytics

    The granularity of ICD-10—which spans procedure laterality plus any number of co-morbidities—gives the nomenclature its descriptive power. But from an analytics perspective, the benefit will be hard to realize for several years. That’s because data mining across two widely divergent vocabularies will be exceedingly difficult.

    The dual sets of data will pose a challenge to insurance underwriters, who typically set rates based on a retrospective analysis of data. “If you are an underwriter, you might look at the last five years,” says Bob Schleichert, associate vice president, information systems, at AultCare, a Canton, Ohio-based health plan. “Four of those years will be in ICD-9 and one in ICD-10 at the beginning. We will need to correlate the two systems one way or another.”


    Fear Factor #9: Transition Expense

    At its heart, ICD-10 is an unfunded mandate, and no money is forthcoming from the government to undertake the transition. Calculating the expense is, for most organizations, mission impossible at this stage.

    Rob Alger, VP of health plan I.T. strategy, the co-leader of Kaiser Permanente’s national ICD-10 transition effort, says Kaiser decided to retire one of its homegrown claims management systems after completing its impact assessment, another element of expense that many providers might overlook, he adds.

    In addition, creating a testing environment can be pricey: the cash outlay on the upgraded testing at Kaiser was more than $10 million, Alger says.


    Fear Factor #10: Trading Partner Readiness

    The ultimate wild card in the ICD-10 transition is the fact that the conversion will depend on the cooperation of thousands of organizations. Having your own house in order is not enough. Your trading partners need to be ready too.

    Bob Schleichert, associate vice president, information systems, at AultCare, a Canton, Ohio-based health plan, says the readiness of trading partners remains an unknown. And AultCare works with some 200 of them, including clearinghouses and providers. “The general sense is that providers are not ready,” he says. “They often look to us for assistance. It they suffer, it trickles down to us.”


    Industry Resources

    A number of Web sites offer ICD-10 tips and preparation guidelines. Here are a few:


    * www.icd10hub.com/

    Offered by American Association of Professional Coding and Navicure, the site includes timelines, white papers, and related news stories.

    * www.ahima.org/icd10

    The American Health Information Management Association site is filled with training materials for coders and other staff

    * www.cms.gov/icd10

    The official CMS site includes technical specs and guidelines for payers, providers and software vendors.

    * www.who.int/classifications/icd/en/

    The World Health Organization’s site includes an online version of the entire classification system.