How OrthoCarolina improved its ability to connect patients and providers

An evolving regulatory landscape focusing on patient privacy is posing challenges for physician group practices trying to efficiently bring in new patients.

Author
Mark Hagland
Save
Share

    Physician practices are beset with manifold challenges these days. Some of them are very obvious, others are considerably less so.

    The physician-owned, physician-led and Charlotte-based OrthoCarolina, the largest orthopedic practice in North Carolina, with 140 orthopedic surgeons, more than 100 physician assistants and 40 office locations in North Carolina and South Carolina, has been thriving in recent years.

    But matching new or prospective patients with the right orthopedists can be a challenge, particularly given regulatory changes in the past couple of years that have made the use of online tracking tools more problematic. Some of that federal regulatory guidance has been amended since, but physician organizations are still moving forward with caution. Here’s a 2024 brief from the McDermott Will and Schulte law firm on the issue.

    In December 2022, the Office for Civil Rights in the Department of Health and Human Services issued guidance stating that HIPAA-covered entities and business associates could not use third-party online tracking tools like pixels and cookies on public-facing websites — tools that help patient care organizations find out how patients/consumers are navigating the web — if they transmitted individually identifiable health information such as IP addresses, page views, or search terms regarding medical conditions, without patient authorization.

    A June 2024 federal court ruling found that the OCR had exceeded some of its regulatory authority in this area. Since then, however, several state governments have stepped into the breach, including the North Carolina legislature, which in the past few years has enacted laws giving consumers the right to opt out of targeted advertising and online data sales and included anti-tracking provisions for many types of business organizations. That legislative action was buttressed by a state court ruling last autumn.

    Taking a new direction

    In the midst of the shifting sands around regulation, the operational leaders at OrthoCarolina made the decision nearly two years ago to innovate in how they connect patients with providers in their practice, both to improve healthcare consumer “stickiness” and to avoid any regulatory issues that might emerge.

    Looking at the regulatory developments beginning in 2022, Blair Primis, OrthoCarolina’s chief growth officer, says, “You had a longstanding goal, and now a legal reason to do it as well” — to re-engineer that process of connecting individual patients to the correct specialists and subspecialists in the practice.

    “How do we best match the right orthopedic doctor or provider with the right patient? We can make sure an incoming patient sees someone who needs a particular specialist, for example, a knee doctor,” Primis explains. “And how do we deliver, with hyper-targetability, the best option for patients to choose a doctor? The easy thing would be to target patients based on their behaviors. But we needed a vendor partner to help us do it effectively, efficiently and in the right way.”

    So Primis and his colleagues at OrthoCarolina turned to the San Francisco-based Freshpaint, a digital-first marketing firm specializing in healthcare.

    “Freshpaint allows for healthcare organizations like ourselves to, in a private and compliant manner, market to patients in a digital world. Their technology protects patient identification and information, but also patient web behavior,” Primis explains. “We run all of our data through our Freshpaint partnership, which allows us to abide by OCR regulations. That was the need. So we started working with them in 2024,” and went live with their solution in January and February 2025.

    The result of the collaboration was an 80-percent drop in cost per lead, ads safely optimized from appointment data in the Epic electronic health record that the group practice uses and eventually a fix to OrthoCarolina’s own booking process that has added about 1,200 more appointments per week.

    Improving the odds

    Tom Spiegelman, Freshpaint’s chief product and technology officer, puts it this way: “Healthcare organizations are consistently putting money into a Google slot machine and hoping to see results. But we’re actually helping connect the dots, so you can take a more measured approach to your marketing spend.

    "Healthcare marketers are up against pressure to do more with less," he adds. "And how do I show my CFO the results of what we’re doing, so that if they cut budget, they realize how they’re impacting the bottom line?”

    Blair Primis and his colleagues, Spiegelman notes, understand the challenge and are eager to apply solutions that combine precision with care for the privacy and preferences of patients and healthcare consumers.

    Importantly, he adds, healthcare consumers want to be connected to the right clinicians. When physician practices can do so in a targeted and efficient way, while adhering to patient privacy principles, those consumers, now active patients of the practice, benefit.

    “At OrthoCarolina, they’re able to better create a much better patient experience so that people can get better care. You’re improving your bottom line because you’ve created a better patient experience,” he emphasizes.

    It’s a win-win all around, OrthoCarolina’s Primis emphasizes. “I think what’s powerful about a partnership like this is that it helps us to build a more sophisticated and marketing platform that generates a better return on investment for the money we’re spending,” he says.

    “And, having been in the marketing communications space for over 30 years, we’re always asking, is this ad working? Is this billboard working? Now, in the past year-plus, I can track campaigns and determine what’s effective. That’s a huge unlock for us.”

    Importantly, he notes, “This partnership allows us to be defensively successful, with regard to the privacy regulations, so our physicians can own the relationship and make sure we’re doing right by the company; and for every dollar we spend, we have to make sure we make money on the investment.” In the end, he concludes, “We’re being good stewards of our investment money.”