Cost control was not enough for Bon Secours Mercy Health’s maternity program
Anna Kammrath’s account sharpened a discussion of benefits that support employees across life stages and measure more than engagement.
Bon Secours Mercy Health moved beyond an internally built maternity program after three years of contained costs failed to produce the birth outcomes it wanted, Anna Kammrath said. The health system sought a broader women’s health solution that could intervene earlier and work with its own clinicians, rather than treating favorable spending alone as sufficient evidence of success.
“Total cost of care was well contained, but we weren't seeing improvements in birth outcomes,” said Kammrath, the system’s director of wellbeing and worklife. She described continuing concerns about neonatal intensive-care use and mothers returning for emergency care. The example made the case for evaluating a benefit against the clinical problem it is intended to solve.
Kammrath joined Dr. Jeff Krauss, Hinge Health’s chief medical officer, and Dr. Roger Shedlin, founder, president and CEO of WIN, for Supporting Employees at Every Life Stage on November 17. Arundhati Parmar, editor-in-chief of MedCity News, moderated, pressing the employer and two benefits providers to explain what remains essential as costs rise and how they substantiate value.
A broader benefit still has to fit the care system
Kammrath described a health-system workforce whose needs span physical work, caregiving and different stages of women’s health. Prevention, musculoskeletal care and cardiometabolic support remain important, she said, alongside access to a clinical team. Employees working around the clock need services that can be used when a conventional appointment is difficult.
The maternity example also showed why the employer’s own clinicians matter. Kammrath said the organization wants clinical stakeholders to understand and support an outside solution because its teams will ultimately care for many employees. A new benefit cannot be judged only as a standalone app when it is meant to connect people with an existing delivery system.
She described extending support from pregnancy into parenting, lactation and menopause. As a Catholic healthcare ministry, the organization does not directly offer fertility benefits, she said, but provides other forms of family support, including adoption benefits and leave. The discussion distinguished that employer’s coverage decisions from the broader family-building model described by WIN.
“ROI should never be an afterthought,” Kammrath said. She wanted a baseline and a measurement approach established before a contract is signed, with comparable populations used to assess change. Engagement can show that people are using a service; it does not, by itself, show that the service improved health or reduced avoidable care.
Compare the people, not just the totals
Krauss said employers increasingly demand evidence of financial returns and more deliberate enrollment of people who need musculoskeletal care. He described using claims information to identify potential participants, alongside expanding Hinge’s scope beyond digital physical therapy to include physicians and an in-person network. Those were descriptions of the company’s approach, not a finding that one route suits every patient.
“The methodology is really important when it comes to ROI and cost savings,” Krauss said. He described comparisons using matched controls, prior utilization, medical history and other characteristics intended to make the groups more similar before measuring subsequent costs. His account emphasized the design of the analysis rather than a single headline return.
Those methods are relevant to assessing vendor claims, but a matched comparison is not automatically the same as a randomized trial. Krauss’s reported savings and clinical measures were company-presented results; the discussion did not provide the complete analyses needed to independently evaluate each estimate. Kammrath’s response reinforced the need to establish the comparison before treating a financial figure as decisive.
Krauss also challenged assumptions about older people’s willingness to use digital care. He described research in which older generations engaged more often and achieved broadly similar outcomes. His practical point was that age alone should not be used to assume a person cannot benefit from a digital service, while the experience and care plan still need to reflect individual needs.
Family support crosses conventional categories
Shedlin described a transition from a fertility benefit toward support that can follow a person through family building, pregnancy, parenting and later responsibilities. The same employee may need help with treatment, a high-risk pregnancy, returning to work and caring for an older parent. Those needs can overlap rather than arriving in tidy, separate stages.
“A very clinically focused, integrated, continuous life stage supporting benefit,” was how Shedlin described the model. He discussed nurse advocates, specialist physicians and additional support such as behavioral health, nutrition and financial counseling. His argument was that a family’s changing circumstances require continuity across services.
He also explained why fertility outcomes offer identifiable measures, including pregnancy, live birth and multiple gestations. Comparing clinical outcomes and appropriate benchmarks can help link care quality with financial consequences. The panel did not establish that a high return reported by one vendor can be assumed for every employer or benefit design.
Kammrath’s experience added a useful qualification to that commercial case. A program can control costs and still leave an important outcome unchanged. Her organization’s decision to seek a more robust service showed how clinical performance can change the purchasing decision even when a narrow financial measure appears acceptable.
The closing discussion of nutrition returned to the same access issue. Kammrath noted that different shifts can make healthy choices harder to obtain. Krauss and Shedlin described nutrition as connected to their respective care programs, reinforcing the need to support decisions people make away from a clinical appointment.
AI should connect the experience without obscuring the clinician
Krauss described AI supporting members in real time, including questions and guidance within an existing care plan. He distinguished those current uses from work on broader intake and diagnostic capabilities. The patient-facing support he described was “not actually diagnosing and not actually treating at this point,” a boundary that matters when evaluating what the tool is being asked to do.
Shedlin emphasized the emotional complexity of fertility and family care. “AI will not replace the clinician,” he said, pointing to the importance of empathy, judgment and human support during difficult moments. He saw a role for technology where its capabilities fit the task, alongside clinically led teams.
Kammrath’s hope was that better connections among services would make an employee’s benefits feel like one coherent source of support. The discussion’s strongest purchasing lesson was to make that experience measurable: define the clinical goal, establish a credible baseline, examine who is actually reached and be willing to change a program when a favorable cost story fails to deliver the health outcome employees need.