Benefits buyers want the business case before the sales presentation

Boeing, AT&T and Yelp leaders described stricter vendor tests and a closer partnership with finance as healthcare costs rise.

Author
HDM Staff
Save
Share
Four employer benefits leaders on the Velocity Stage before the audience
Benefit Leaders Tell All brings employer benefits executives together on November 17. Photo credit: HLTH USA 2026

    Boeing’s Brodie Dychinco described requiring prospective benefits partners to answer structured questions in a two-page document before presenting a slide deck. The process begins with clinical credibility, then examines financial value and experience, giving the employer evidence it can use in its own business case rather than allowing a vendor’s preferred presentation to define the meeting.

    That buying discipline was one of the most concrete responses to rising healthcare costs in the November 17 Benefit Leaders Tell All discussion. Executives from Boeing, AT&T and Yelp described different approaches to affordability, but agreed that vendors must explain where they fit, what changes over time and how a benefits team can defend the investment.

    Dychinco, Boeing’s executive director of health and wellbeing, joined Ben Jackson, vice president of global benefits and HR mergers and acquisitions at AT&T Business, and Christopher Lee, Yelp’s vice president of total rewards and mobility. Jennifer Calhoun Mohl, specialty growth leader at Marsh Health & Benefits, facilitated the discussion around cost pressure, available interventions and the challenge of defending health spending to senior leadership.

    Control the questions before judging the answer

    Dychinco said buyers often negotiate the length of a vendor meeting without determining how it will be conducted. His alternative is to establish the evaluation gates first. If the underlying science is not sound, there is little reason to spend the rest of the meeting discussing a polished commercial proposition.

    “We define how the presentation will go,” Dychinco said. The structured document also asks a prospective partner to do some of the work needed to support an internal investment decision. It gives the employer a more consistent basis for comparing opportunities and makes the vendor’s assumptions easier to examine.

    He connected that discipline to employee tenure. A workforce that stays for decades gives an employer a different planning horizon from one whose employees remain only a few years. Dychinco described Boeing’s investment in accessible primary-care settings as an example of decisions supported by a longer relationship with the population being served.

    The distinction is not that a short-tenure employer should ignore health improvement. It is that the timing and ownership of a financial return change the business case. Removing immediate friction may be valuable in either setting, while longer-term investments require an explicit explanation of who benefits and when.

    Know which costs are actually moving

    Lee described Yelp responding to a double-digit cost increase by examining spending at a more detailed participant level. His team looked at differences among employees, spouses and children, as well as which plans people selected. That analysis helped guide changes to choice and affordability rather than treating the entire increase as an undifferentiated problem.

    “We can't manage what we can't see,” Lee said. He described engaging employees in a more direct conversation about what the company could absorb and where people would face different choices. Expanded options were part of the response, alongside explaining the shared financial pressures.

    For vendors, his advice was equally specific. “Know where you fit in the stack for the company you're going into,” Lee said. A supplier needs to understand the employer’s priorities before assuming its own definition of the problem is the one the buyer shares.

    He asked for financial returns and people outcomes, explained in terms the benefits team can carry to the CFO or CEO. Where the payoff is several years away, the vendor should show what happens in the intervening years. A distant modeled total is less useful than a clear sequence of capabilities, participation and expected results.

    Quality remains a choice under pressure

    Jackson said AT&T had shifted its emphasis from trying to create highly informed healthcare shoppers toward navigating people to quality care. When costs began rising more sharply, the team revisited that philosophy and chose to reinforce it rather than abandon it. He described examining lower-quality offerings and programs without a clear return as early candidates for removal.

    “We kind of doubled down on quality,” Jackson said. He argued that employers should use their scale to demand accountability from partners. Cost pressure makes it more important to know whether an intervention delivers what was promised, rather than simply whether it appears on a competitive benefits list.

    “Hold our partners accountable for what they say they're going to deliver,” Jackson said. His framework also allowed room for benefits whose value is connected to workforce strategy, even when the short-term financial calculation is incomplete. Family-support programs, for example, can address retention and skills needs identified with talent and workforce-planning colleagues.

    He cautioned that such investments still need a strong connection to corporate priorities. The panel did not present cultural value and financial discipline as mutually exclusive. It described a portfolio in which some returns can be measured more directly than others, with a reason for including each component.

    Dychinco also described conventional purchasing work as part of Boeing’s response: running competitive requests, renegotiating contracts and using available market checks. His account paired those measures with limits on shifting costs to employees. A stronger innovation pipeline did not remove the need to examine existing commercial terms.

    Finance should help build the case

    Dychinco described a practice from his earlier work at Amazon: asking finance staff to write the return-on-investment section of a proposal. That moved disagreements about assumptions earlier and gave the eventual decision-makers a model developed with their own colleagues. At Boeing, he described quarterly advisory discussions bringing strategy and finance together around difficult questions.

    “You want all the drama in advance,” Dychinco said. His objective was a final presentation that becomes a formality because the substantive debate has already happened. He also described separating value that finance will quantify from value it recognizes without assigning dollars, and claims it is not yet ready to recognize at all.

    Jackson and Lee described similar changes in their relationships with finance. More frequent conversations about cost forecasts created opportunities to explain benefits strategy and find allies. Lee emphasized one coherent narrative that can be expressed differently to employees, finance and the CEO while remaining consistent about the direction of travel.

    For employees, that narrative must explain what choices mean in practical terms. For finance, it must make the assumptions and timing visible. For a potential partner, the lesson is to arrive prepared to support both conversations: clinical credibility first, a transparent path to value and a relationship that continues after the contract is signed.