3 Challenges to a Consistent Data Incident Response

Information security vendor ID Experts, which also offers breach remediation services, notes that the 2014 Verizon Data Breach Investigations Report cited 63,437 security incidents from just 50 organizations. That is 1,268 incidents per organization per year.

Author
HDM Staff
Save
Share

    3 Challenges to a Consistent Data Incident Response

    Information security vendor ID Experts, which also offers breach remediation services, notes that the 2014 Verizon Data Breach Investigations Report cited 63,437 security incidents from just 50 organizations. That is 1,268 incidents per organization per year.

    Despite the frequency of security incidents, healthcare organizations and others struggle with how they respond to privacy incidents. Data used to reside in the data center, and then came distributed systems that link locations; mobile computing provides links to employees and customers. “Today, there is no perimeter,” according to ID Experts. “Business advantage follows where the data flows, leaving the CISO to safeguard data that can be in use or in transit anytime, and often anywhere in the world.” The vendor offers three challenges organizations will face when developing a coordinated and consistent incident response process. (Photo: Fotolia)


    The Phases of Incident Response

    Processes associated with incident response include incident discovery, containment, investigation and documentation, as well as assessment and notification. Assessment is especially important because it determines whether an incident is a breach that legally must be reported.

    “Too often, however, security sees incident assessment as a privacy function,” ID Experts contends. “The complex nature of incidents encompasses more than regulatory know-how, though. It includes understanding the technical aspects of an incident—the nature and severity of an incident, the nature and sensitivity of the affected data, and remediation. Effective incident assessment bridges the gap between technical and legal aspects, so privacy and security professionals can accurately determine if an incident is a breach that legally requires notification.” (Photo: Fotolia)


    Challenge 1: Incident Detection

    Even though data no longer can be contained within a security perimeter, many organizations still lack the ability to detect and mitigate threats in a timely manner. “Instead of taking a holistic view, privacy and security teams tend to focus their efforts on certain aspects,” according to ID Experts. “Information security, for example, may overlook the human factor when it comes to safeguarding sensitive data.” An Ernst & Young security survey in 2014 found that 38 percent of respondents said employee carelessness or lack of awareness was the primary threat resulting in increased risk exposure. (Photo: Fotolia)


    Challenge 2: Complex Breach Notification Requirements

    Organizations face a web of confusing federal and state privacy regulations, including 47 state data breach notification laws that vary and can conflict. What may be “only” an incident in one state could be a reportable data breach in another. Consequently, the Obama Administration has proposed a national breach notification law that would preempt state laws.

    For now, each jurisdiction that may have enforcement oversight requires a separate incident assessment, so a multi-state organization might be faced with the prospects of conducting an assessment in each state it operates in along with a HIPAA-mandated assessment. The same can happen with breach notifications--a series of separate notifications, each complying with different state regulations. “Whatever assessment or notification requirements there are, the burden of proof always rests with the organization, not the regulators,” ID Experts says. (Photo: Fotolia)


    Challenge 3: Lack of Financial and Human Resources

    Incident response and related activities are not high on the budget priority list, ID Experts notes. A Ponemon Institute survey found that half of IT and security professional respondents said less than 10 percent of their security budgets are designated for incident response. Further, despite a 26 percent increase in data breaches across industries in the past year, only a third of respondent organizations planned to increase funds for incident response this year.

    A shortage of qualified staff across industries also hinders an effective response strategy. Ponemon found that if an organization has a computer security response team, its members often don’t have ongoing specialized training, and nearly half of the teams have no full-time employees. (Photo: Fotolia)


    What to Do?

    Effective incident response requires a collaborative approach, breaking down departmental silos, as well as a security operations center. “In addition to organization alignment, privacy and security professionals must create consistent, scalable and repeatable processes for managing incident response,” ID Experts advises. “Consistency ensures best practices are made operational, especially compliant incident assessment. The process should be repeatable yet flexible, and scalable as the nature and volume of incidents change.”

    Incident management also calls for a plan for implementing notifications and identity protection to comply with legal obligations and address potential harm to those affected. (Photo: Fotolia)


    The report, “Challenges of Managing Privacy Incident Response,” is available here for free. . Brief registration is required.