10 Big Question Marks About ICD-10

…

Author
HDM Staff
Save
Share

    ICD-10 Question Marks Loom on the Horizon

    ICD-10, the massive new coding and classification system, is set to take effect beginning October 2014. In the following slides, HDM reporter Gary Baldwin—who has covered ICD-10 for several years—lays out key questions about the system looming in the industry. A successful transition to the system, which has been delayed multiple times by CMS, is critical. ICD-10 drives clinical documentation on the inpatient side and is critical to reimbursement for both hospital and professional services.


    Question 1: Does the industry understand the impact?

    Bob Schwyn, a consultant at Aspen Advisors, says his biggest challenge in working with clients in preparing for ICD-10 is getting them to understand its vast impact. “It impacts HIM directly and there are implications downstream for claims and the revenue cycle.”


    Question 2: Can ‘silent pockets’ be identified?

    Provider organizations tackling the transition say the coding system reaches wide and deep in the operation. Children’s Hospital of Colorado, for example, identified some 4,000 systems, applications and databases housing ICD codes that will need to be updated. HIM director Melinda Patten frets that other “silent pockets” remain unidentified in the health system, including research databases.


    Question 3: Will payers be ready?

    ICD-10 affects all players in the revenue stream. Even for provider organizations on top of their internal remediation efforts, questions loom about the readiness of payers. “We are seeing delays on the payer side and not getting a lot of feedback from them,” says Jackie Griffin at Gateway EDI, a clearinghouse. “The plans of many payers are very vague.”


    Question 4: Can group practices afford it?

    Associations like the Medical Group Management Association have been vocal about what they describe as ICD-10’s heavy burden on group practices. MGMA survey data reveal an expensive transition in the making. About 30% of practices will have ICD-10 software upgrades covered under current maintenance agreements, but the others face a hefty bill—some $10,000 per physician for both the practice management and EHR systems.


    Question 5: Can Claims Tests Be Run?

    Industry advocacy groups like WEDI urge that claims testing be conducted well before the ICD-10 go-live. CMS announced it will side-step any transactions testing, a policy widely criticized in the industry as setting the wrong example for the commercial sector. “The challenge is full end-to-end testing with payers,” says Bob Schwyn, Aspen Advisors.


    Question 6: What happens to coder productivity?

    Meg McGill, HIM director at Memphis-based Methodist Hospital, says coder productivity is all but guaranteed to drop, at least during the early phases of ICD-10. The new system reclassifies codes and adds tens of thousands of new ones describing procedures and diagnoses—key drivers of inpatient facility billing. “The slower I am in coding, the slower bills go out,” McGill says.


    Question 7: Will physicians document appropriately?

    Physicians too face increased demands for more specificity in their clinical documentation. That’s because ICD-10 includes more detailed descriptions of procedure laterality and other factors in describing disease states. Many in the industry are scrambling now to educate physicians.


    Question 8: What is the destiny of legacy databases?

    In the era of accountable care, health systems are building large-scale data warehouses to house clinical, financial and outcomes data. That data will need to be transitioned to ICD-10 in order to keep analytics efforts standardized.


    Question 9: What Happens to Reimbursement?

    Even those organizations well-prepared for ICD-10 don't know the answer to this question. If payers aren't ready, their claims may be delayed or denied. And even if claims go through, medical payment policies remain unclear. That's why some organizations analyzing which service lines will likely be most impacted and starting their remediation efforts there.


    Question 10: Will CMS stick to its enforcement schedule?

    CMS has postponed implementation of ICD-10 several times, a fact not lost on on ICD-10 advocates who say the USA lags behind other countries, such as Canada, which implemented the system years ago. The delays have cost the government credibility, many experts say. “Small practices are not even thinking about ICD-10,” says Jackie Griffin, Gateway EDI. “Many expect another delay.”


    Further reading

    The October issue of Health Data Management includes an in-depth look at ICD-10.