> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://www.healthdatacon.io/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# The Stories Behind Big Breaches Reported in 2Q 2013
- URL: https://www.healthdatacon.io/articles/the-stories-behind-big-breaches-reported-in-2q-2013/
- Published: 2013-07-22T01:52:57.000Z
- Updated: 2026-11-10T10:55:08.000Z
- Description: 
- Author: HDM Staff
- Tags: Health IT

*Health Data Management* tracked 19 major breaches of protected health information reported during the second quarter of 2013, affecting 537 to 189,489 patients. Many of the breaches occurred in the first quarter, but organizations have 60 days to report incidents from the time of discovery, which launches an investigation to confirm, determine the severity and affected patients, and notify them. Here are the stories behind the breaches.  

  
## Identity Theft

![](https://hdmpublishing.wpengine.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/11/p180215gtsumoaek1bllqmua36.jpg)

Continuing a trend of thieves stealing medical records to commit identity theft, the University of Florida reported two such breaches in the second quarter, and two other organizations also had ID theft incidents. In April, at least 14,339 patients at UF&Shands Family Medical at Main Clinic in Gainesville were notified, and in late May another 5,682 patients at UF Health Pediatrics-Tower in Gainesville got notifications of a separate incident after employees at both clinics were found to have ties to an identity theft ring.  
  
In May, Bon Secours Mary Immaculate Hospital in Suffolk, Va., notified about 5,000 patients after discovering a significant amount of inappropriate access to records between April 2012 and April 2013\. Sutter Health in California notified 4,500 individuals in June that they were at risk for identity theft. The four facilities offered paid ID protection services.

  
## Stealing X-rays

![](https://hdmpublishing.wpengine.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/11/p180215pvkkgm19m59e5eel17ek7.jpg)

ID theft isnt the only reason thieves target health records. El Centro Regional Medical Center in California and Raleigh Orthopaedic Clinic in North Carolina became some the latest hospitals to have X-rays stolen for their silver content. Similar thefts in the past year have been reported in seven states, as well as several Canadian cities. Some vendors contracted to digitize or destroy film are instead extracting the silver.  
  
El Centros theft affected 189,489 patients and the Raleigh theft affected 17,300\. El Centro initially was not forthcoming on the number of affected patients, but eventually had to report the total to the HHS Office for Civil Rights.

  
## Burglaries

![](https://hdmpublishing.wpengine.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/11/p1802166tr1i1hjd88061k9io2n8.jpg)

The theft of unencrypted laptops from homes or cars caused at least four organizations to report breaches. United HomeCare in Miami notified more than 13,600 patients and offered two years of paid credit protection monitoring. Indiana University Health Arnett Hospital notified 10,300 and is not offering protection services as a stolen laptop contained demographic and some clinical information but not financial data or Social Security numbers. The university now has three major breaches since August 2011.  
  
Arizona Counseling and Treatment Services in Yuma notified about 3,000 following the theft of a laptop and external hard drive. The laptop was embedded with tracking software and disabled. The hard drive was vulnerable but did not contain financial data or Social Security numbers. Still, patients were offered paid credit monitoring services. Washington State Department of Social and Health Services notified 652 clients after a psychologists laptop was stolen, but offered no protection services. Compromised data included names, ID numbers, psychological evaluations and diagnoses, birth and service dates, addresses and the last four digits of SSNs.

  
## Judgment Calls

![](https://hdmpublishing.wpengine.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/11/p180216fgb1m0f78oedn1059r869.jpg)

On the surface, one breach clearly should have resulted in patients getting protective services and they didnt, while not offering services may have been justified for another organization that wound giving credit protection. An unauthorized individual or company copied all or parts of the electronic health records system at Sight and Sun Eyeworks Gulf Breeze in Gulf Breeze, Fla., affecting about 9,000 patients. Clinical and financial data along with SSNs were compromised, but the organization decided the records were accessed only to offer patients other medical services and not to commit identity theft, it said in a notice. However, patients should closely monitor their credit card, bank and other financial statements for signs of fraud and identity theft.  
  
A burglary at Hospice of Alamance Caswell in Burlington, N.C., resulted in the theft of three laptops that encrypted patient data, but also unencrypted emails contained protected information on a small number of patients. The thieves also had access to paper medical and billing records, although it appears they were not viewed. But the hospice offered free credit monitoring services for a year to 5,370 patients or next of kin, and now encrypts emails.

  
## Lost Records = Breaches

![](https://hdmpublishing.wpengine.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/11/p180216rrj164sbiaii31ncl125ja.jpg)

At least three organizations reporting breaches in the second quarter lost medical records. William Jennings Bryan Dorn VA Medical Center in Columbia, S.C., notified 7,400 after discovering a laptop connected to a medical device that tests pulmonary function was missing and offered one year of credit and ID theft service.  
  
Paper medical records at Jackson Health System in Miami were in transit to be electronically scanned or were being returned when they disappeared. There was no breach of financial information or SSNs, but 1,407 patients were offered credit and identity protection services. University of Rochester Medical Center in New York notified 537 patients after a physicians flash drive went missing. Demographic and some clinical information were on the device but no SSNs, insurance numbers or addresses. The hospital is not offering paid protection services, believing the potential for abuse is low.

  
## Sloppy Mistakes

![](https://hdmpublishing.wpengine.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/11/p180217eebub010331s11pth1303b.jpg)

Three large breaches resulted from clerical errors and, in one case, probably a record for quick notification. Dent Neurologic Institute in Amherst, N.Y., experienced a breach on May 13 and issued a public notice on May 14 as it prepared to notify about 10,000 patients and their referring physicians. The clerical error occurred when a list of patients was inadvertently attached to an email sent to 200 patients. The email was intended to update patients and physicians on activities at the institute and educational events. Regional Medical Center at Memphis notified 1,200 patients after an innocent employee mistake sent out unsecured emails with attachments containing PHI. The hospital offered credit monitoring services.  
  
A data entry error at contractor Siemens Healthcare in which patients received bills with incorrect information caused notification of 8,330 patients of Louisiana State University Health System in Shreveport. The error caused names and treatment information for one patient to incorrectly align with another persons mailing address, according to a notice. The university believes no financial information was compromised as no SSNs, financial account numbers or dates of birth were in the billings. This incident resulted from a unique configuration and incorrect data provided by LSU, who is using a non-Siemens product for enterprise financials that feeds data, Siemens said in a statement.

  
## Watch Those Upgrades

![](https://hdmpublishing.wpengine.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/11/p180217uqrlmmfs4o1ddq1mf3c.jpg)

A mistake while updating the Web site of Sonoma Valley Hospital in California preceded notification to 1,350 surgery patients. An employee accidently uploaded personal health information that was not directly accessible on the site, but was accessible through a search engine. Posted information included name, date of service, procedure, surgeon, hospital charges and the name of the insurance company. We have apologized to the patients involved for our error and assured them that we have taken action to understand the cause of the breach and strengthened policies and controls protecting patient information, said Richard Reid, CFO and compliance officer.