> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://www.healthdatacon.io/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# Stability Returns after Supreme Court Ruling on the ACA
- URL: https://www.healthdatacon.io/articles/stability-returns-after-supreme-court-ruling-on-the-aca/
- Published: 2015-06-26T00:22:19.000Z
- Updated: 2026-11-10T10:52:02.000Z
- Description: After Thursdays Supreme Court ruling upholding subsides on the federally facilitated marketplace, the industry was quick to react. Industry insiders give insights on what the court decision means for the Affordable Care Act, exchanges, providers and their healthcare IT plans.
- Author: HDM Staff
- Tags: Policy

## Stability Returns after Supreme Court Ruling on the ACA

After Thursdays Supreme Court ruling upholding subsides on the federally facilitated marketplace, the industry was quick to react. Industry insiders give insights on what the court decision means for the Affordable Care Act, exchanges, providers and their healthcare IT plans.

  
## Sigh of Relief for Healthcare Information Technology

![](https://hdmpublishing.wpengine.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/11/p19omj8dbf1dakhdcs1p1od8irt7.jpg)

In addition to the insurance provisions, preservation of the ACA leaves in place a variety of important healthcare IT provisions. These include statewide health insurance exchanges, and the associated technologies they employ; electronic enrollment in health and human services programs; and a new tax on medical devices, including those collecting and/or transmitting data.  
  
Preservation of the ACA also offers a boost to some efforts to improve the exchange of healthcare information. These include new HIPAA transactions for electronic fund transfers, remittance advice and claims attachments, as well as a health plan identifier. Finally, analytics gets a boost because of the increased availability of Medicare claims data. (Photo: Fotolia)

  
## Some IT Issues Remain in a Holding Pattern

![](https://hdmpublishing.wpengine.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/11/p19omj8shu1mua1vu7ssfprlgc8.jpg)

Steven Lazarus, president of Boundary Information Group, a Denver-based consultancy, says a significant aspect of the ruling is that future challenges to the law will have to show that the intent of a disputed provision is not clear, and the challenge also will have to consider the entirety of intent.  
  
While implementation of ACA can continue, there are some information technology-related issues in a holding pattern, Lazarus notes. Rules for certifying that health plans are compliant with HIPAA operating rules are delayed, as is the health plan identifier. He believes HHS will now focus on resources for the Healthcare.gov exchange and other internal information system security enhancements. (Photo: Fotolia)

  
## Judicial Overreach

![](https://hdmpublishing.wpengine.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/11/p19omj9c7lkkd7i28oi1gf1fgo9.jpg)

Avik Roy, senior fellow at the conservative Manhattan Institute for Policy Research, disagreed with the ruling. The majority opinion is a classic case of Supreme Court justices legislating from the bench, he said in a statement. As Associate Justice Antonin Scalia put it, We should start calling this law SCOTUScare. The plain reading of the Affordable Care Acts statutory text is that subsidies can only flow through the exchanges established by states. (Photo: Fotolia)

  
## Clear Intent

![](https://hdmpublishing.wpengine.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/11/p19omj9rmufvq3dohl91n6iodca.jpg)

Denise Hanna, health law attorney at Locke Lord LLP in Washington, DC, says when looking at the ACA in its entirety, the court saw the intent clear that subsidies would be widely available, despite a handful of words that indicated otherwise. I think they recognized this isnt a matter of saying the right things in the right places.  
  
The law clearly authorized the three-prong mandate of guaranteed issue, a coverage mandate and subsidies, she adds. Other reform efforts have failed for lack of these three prongs; Massachusetts had them and succeeded. Thats why they were put in the ACA. Hanna also believes the court was not prepared to watch the nations health insurance system implode. (Photo: Fotolia)

  
## Role of State Rights

![](https://hdmpublishing.wpengine.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/11/p19omjacrvf576of1ip1170c1krnb.jpg)

Bill Melville, market analyst at consultancy Decision Resources Group, was surprised that Justice Kennedy, a federalist who strongly supports state rights, joined the 6-3 majority. He believes Kennedy was comfortable with a law that gave each state options on the exchanges, including building its own, building/operating in partnership with the federal government, or refusing to participate and having the feds put in the exchange.  
  
This may not be the last ACA ruling by the Supreme Court, Melville says, but its very likely the last one that could have sent the law into a death spiral. (Photo: Fotolia)

  
## Relief at the State Level

![](https://hdmpublishing.wpengine.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/11/p19omjaqur1m3t1d2h1n2sjsh4nec.jpg)

The National Academy for State Health Policy, which represents state policymakers, in a statement said the court decision avoided a crisis for states and their insurance markets. The wait and see period is over and now states can move forward. The group called on leaders in the states relying on a federal exchange to improve coordination between their Medicaid and CHIP programs with the exchange, and consider ways to make coverage more affordable. (Photo: Fotolia)