> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://www.healthdatacon.io/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# ICD-10: Why So Sad?
- URL: https://www.healthdatacon.io/articles/icd-10-why-so-sad/
- Published: 2011-12-07T17:27:54.000Z
- Updated: 2026-11-10T10:57:20.000Z
- Description: 
- Author: HDM Staff
- Tags: Informatics

## ICD-10: Why So Sad?

Changing to ICD-10 diagnosis and procedure coding is a nail-biter for I.T. staff, health information managers, billing departments, and pretty much anyone who has to document anything about patient care.  
  
Nonetheless, once it's all done, there may be reasons to be glad that the United States brought its coding practices into the 21st century. Following are some reasons to look forward to ICD-10, as reported by Elizabeth Gardner in HDMs December edition.  

  
## Replacing a Creaky Mess

![](https://hdmpublishing.wpengine.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/11/p16gcon7ud7m01or41i6tu6l5m6.jpg)

ICD-9 is a creaky mess and going to ICD-10 is as much of a no-brainer,, contends Sue Bowman, director of coding policy and compliance at AHIMA.  
  
  
"I don't think most other countries have looked at the transition like the U.S. has," she says. "They assumed that the need to move to the next version was obvious, because the newer version is more clinically relevant and up to date, because ICD-9 lacks space, and because it's necessary to maintain global data comparability."  

  
## Going Global

![](https://hdmpublishing.wpengine.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/11/p16gconb9816hi1einopq18k21kp07.jpg)

While no other country uses ICD codes quite the way the U.S. does, 138 countries use ICD-10 for tracking mortality, 99 use it for tracking morbidity, and Canada, Australia, and several European countries use it for some form of case-mix or reimbursement management.

  
## Analyzing Public Health

![](https://hdmpublishing.wpengine.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/11/p16gconeghdg31dkc1fs21c6614ar8.jpg)

The U.S. version--ICD-10-CMcontains nearly six times more codes than the international version maintained by the World Health Organization. ICD-10 also contains numerous new distinctions that will be useful day to day. For example, unlike ICD-9, ICD-10 distinguishes easily and thoroughly among the various types of diabetes.  
  
"\[Type 2\] diabetes is one of the most critical public health issues facing us, and ICD-10 will provide us with so much more information," , says consultant Steven Steindel, formerly the CDC's director of data standards and vocabulary and CDC liaison to the NCVHS. ICD-10 has more than 250 diabetes-related codes, separating Type 1, Type 2, gestational diabetes, and diabetes caused by various drugs or other underlying conditions.  

  
## Expanding Chapters

![](https://hdmpublishing.wpengine.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/11/p16gcongnm5mf1u0551iiks1gae9.jpg)

A comparison of ICD-10 (the U.S.-specific clinical modification) with ICD-9-CM chapter by chapter finds that some chapters grew a lot more than others. The ones dealing with diseases of the respiratory system and digestive system have only about 40 percent more codes than the corresponding chapters of ICD-9.  
  
The chapter dealing with the musculoskeletal system and connective tissue has 16 times more codes, partly because for the first time it includes separate codes for left and right, and digits on hands and feet (521 for each finger and more than a thousand for the thumb).  

  
## Key Distinctions

![](https://hdmpublishing.wpengine.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/11/p16gconirvvngq6dru2ju0750a.jpg)

The big explosion (theres a bunch of codes for that, including injuries caused by fireworks, boiler explosions and tire, pipe or hose explosions) comes in the chapter enumerating causes of injury, which is 26 times bigger than ICD-9 and includes apparent wackiness like separate codes for injuries from water skis catching on fire and injuries from water skis being crushed.  
  
  
However, such distinctions could provide key product safety information to manufacturers and regulators. And the odds are that only coders in resort areas will ever need them.  

  
## Follow the Thinking

![](https://hdmpublishing.wpengine.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/08/p16gconlavlpt1oud1g0l4e13mub.jpg)

Some of the increased specificity was pushed by medical societies to better reflect how physicians think, says Kim Reid, director of ICD-10 development and training for the American Association of Professional Coders, whose members work predominantly with physicians. For example, the chapter covering pregnancy now divides the codes up by trimester, to match how physicians assess pregnant patients.  
  
"We might need to use a few different ICD-9 codes to describe a disease state and all its symptoms, but with ICD-10 we can often do the same thing with just one code," she says. Theoretically, codes that correspond more closely with diagnoses should increase the accuracy of payment and reduce the risk that claims will be kicked back for incorrect coding. "Physicians don't get paid on diagnosis codes, but they support the medical necessity of the procedures or the evaluation and management that's done," she says.  

  
## Readability Factor

![](https://hdmpublishing.wpengine.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/11/p16gconnfn5o5sadrvskngq5hc.jpg)

ICD-10 is also more "readable" and less arbitrary than ICD-9, says consultant Steven Steindel, formerly the CDC's director of data standards and vocabulary and CDC liaison to the NCVHS. Even though there are a lot more codes, a trained coder can quickly narrow down the choices through deduction, much the way a librarian can predict a book's call number and location on the shelves by knowing its topic and author.  
  
An ICD-10 code has four to seven alphanumeric characters (compared with ICD-9's three to five), enabling millions of additional combinations and making it easy to add new distinctions, diagnoses (like SARS) or procedures (like robotic surgery, gene-based therapies, and other treatments that haven't been invented yet). "Practically speaking, there's no limitation at all," Steindel says.  

  
## Could be Worse

![](https://hdmpublishing.wpengine.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/11/p16gconphn1lv01fd7ncr1s1s19cvd.jpg)

If you think ICD-10 is detailed, check out the 300,000+-term Systematized Nomenclature of Medicine Clinical Terms (aka SNOMED-CT). Maintained by an international organization and promoted by the National Library of Medicine, it can be used to standardize and aggregate clinical data for the kind of computerized analysis that underlies quality measurement and clinical decision support systems.  
  
If everyone used SNOMED-CT, we'd be swimming in useful data, fewer than 50 provider organizations do, says consultant Steven Steindel, formerly the CDC's director of data standards and vocabulary and CDC liaison to the NCVHS. Most are just trying to get bills out and don't have resources or inclination to embrace an additional system for research and quality improvement.