> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://www.healthdatacon.io/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# Emanuel and Blase agree Medicare should narrow payment gaps between hospitals and doctors’ offices
- URL: https://www.healthdatacon.io/articles/hlth-emanuel-blase-medicare-site-neutral-payments/
- Published: 2026-11-17T18:55:00.000Z
- Updated: 2026-11-18T06:35:38.000Z
- Description: The two policy experts also called for changes to surprise-billing arbitration. Their agreement broke down over how to keep people insured.
- Author: HDM Staff
- Tags: Policy, Americas, HLTH

LAS VEGAS — Ezekiel J. Emanuel and Brian Blase told a Main Stage audience Tuesday that Congress should tackle the differences in what Medicare pays for comparable services depending on where patients receive them. The two health policy experts also called for changes to the process insurers and providers use to settle out-of-network payment disputes. They split over Medicaid eligibility and the role of insurance regulation in keeping premiums affordable.

Mandy Cohen, a national adviser at Manatt Health and former director of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, moderated the [HLTH debate](https://hlth.com/events/usa/agenda?date=2026-11-17&stages=fcbd0952-1966-45a8-bbd1-512442bf78ab&ref=healthdatacon.io). She asked Emanuel, the University of Pennsylvania’s vice provost for global initiatives, and Blase, president of the Paragon Health Institute, to distinguish what families pay from the underlying prices that drive those bills. Blase joined remotely. The pair had already published a [joint argument](https://ldi.upenn.edu/our-work/research-updates/reaching-across-the-aisle-to-lower-health-care-costs/?ref=healthdatacon.io) for reducing some site-of-care payment differences. Onstage, Cohen pushed them to explain why the changes remain difficult and where their approaches diverge.

## When ownership changes the bill

Blase argued for a straightforward Medicare principle. The program “shouldn’t pay more for services in a hospital than in a doctor’s office,” he said. He connected that difference to an incentive for hospital systems to buy practices when the same kinds of services can command higher payments under hospital ownership. He also said hospital lobbying gives Congress a political reason to move cautiously on an issue that could change providers’ revenue.

Emanuel used a bone marrow biopsy as an example of a service that can be performed in different outpatient settings. The prices can be “wildly different,” he said. His point was that patients may encounter different charges for similar care depending on where the service is billed. He also argued that influential hospital systems can make a broad legislative change difficult. The panel offered a concrete way to ask which payments should differ. For a service that can be provided safely in more than one place, what extra capability does a higher payment buy?

Medicare already applies site-specific rules, and the policy is more complicated than setting one uniform rate for outpatient care. The agency’s [2027 outpatient rule](https://www.cms.gov/newsroom/fact-sheets/calendar-year-2027-hospital-outpatient-prospective-payment-system-opps-ambulatory-surgical-center-0?ref=healthdatacon.io) addresses payments for specified outpatient services and departments. The rule applies the physician fee schedule rate to certain imaging without contrast at qualifying off-campus hospital departments and exempts rural sole community hospitals. The broader approach debated Tuesday would require determining which services are comparable, where a hospital’s capacity or standby obligations justify a different payment, and how safeguards should apply in markets with few alternatives. The panelists were arguing for policy action. Their discussion did not itself change the rules that govern hospital or physician billing.

## A second point of agreement on surprise billing

The two also agreed that Congress should revisit the arbitration system tied to the No Surprises Act. Blase said the system provided “significant incentives for providers to stay out of network.” Emanuel said changes should address how payment disputes are settled. Both argued that the design of arbitration can affect what insurers and providers negotiate even when a claim never goes through the formal process.

Under the [federal process](https://www.cms.gov/initiatives/no-surprise-billing/overview/notices?ref=healthdatacon.io), eligible disputes over certain out-of-network payments can go to independent dispute resolution. That process addresses payment between a provider and a health plan after the patient’s applicable cost-sharing is determined. For employers and purchasers, the question raised onstage is how the awards change the cost of contracting with providers. For patients, the immediate question is whether they keep the law’s billing protections when lawmakers redesign the way the two sides settle.

Cohen also asked how Congress could address the cost of administration. Emanuel called for more standardized billing and documentation. Blase agreed that the system is hard to navigate, then said he would remove the Affordable Care Act’s medical loss ratio requirement. Emanuel was more open to retaining the requirement alongside stronger competition enforcement. Their answers separate two problems that often get discussed together. One is the work associated with administering coverage across many payers. The other is how regulators constrain what insurers can spend on work outside medical care and quality improvement.

## Coverage exposed the wider divide

Emanuel urged Congress to extend coverage to uninsured children and called Medicaid work requirements “paperwork requirements.” He argued that more frequent eligibility checks could make it harder for people to retain coverage and could generate administrative work. Blase defended the direction of changes to Medicaid financing that he said restrain excessive payments to hospital systems. He also said Paragon was examining a proposal to move Medicaid expansion enrollees into a subsidized individual insurance market. Emanuel expressed interest in making programs more coherent, while raising concerns about deductibles and the coverage available through exchanges.

The distinction is timely because states are preparing to put federal Medicaid eligibility changes into practice. CMS issued an [interim final rule](https://www.cms.gov/newsroom/fact-sheets/medicaid-community-engagement-requirement-certain-individuals-interim-final-rule-comment-period-cms?ref=healthdatacon.io) in June implementing a statutory community engagement requirement for certain adults. On November 13 the agency announced an optional [transition period](https://www.cms.gov/newsroom/press-releases/cms-announces-hold-harmless-period-strengthen-medicaid-work-requirement-systems-improve-beneficiary?ref=healthdatacon.io) through June 30, 2027, for states implementing by January 1\. The announcement gives participating states time to improve their systems and processes. The requirement remains in statute.

The operational implications differ from those of Medicare payment changes. A payment change affects the amount a system or practice receives for a service. An eligibility change affects whether a person has coverage when they seek that service. Providers and payers would have to track the results separately, including whether outpatient care shifts to a lower-cost setting, whether coverage gaps increase and whether patients still reach an ongoing source of care.

Cohen’s questions revealed where agreement might be sufficient to advance a targeted change. Emanuel and Blase offered a common starting point on comparable outpatient payments and on the incentives created by surprise-billing arbitration. Their discussion of Medicaid showed that agreement on costs does not settle how to distribute coverage or what administrative friction families should face to keep it.

The panel also made clear why the details of a payment bill matter. A narrower provision tied to services routinely delivered in offices would have different consequences from equalizing payments for a broad set of outpatient services. Congress would have to decide the scope, the phase-in and how to assess effects on access as the policy takes hold.

*Ezekiel Emanuel and Mandy Cohen onstage with Brian Blase joining remotely. Photo credit: HLTH USA 2026.*