> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://www.healthdatacon.io/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# Handling Data Breaches: The Bad and the Good
- URL: https://www.healthdatacon.io/articles/handling-data-breaches-the-bad-and-the-good/
- Published: 2013-09-08T02:00:18.000Z
- Updated: 2026-11-10T10:55:02.000Z
- Description: 
- Author: HDM Staff
- Tags: Cybersecurity

Breaches involving data of interest to credit and identity thieves continue unabated. One would assume that when fraud is possible, breach victims are offered credit and/or identity theft protection services. But that precaution is not commonly offered. For instance, *Health Data Management* over a two-month span tracked nine breaches where affected individuals were warned of the threat of credit or identity theft. Eight of the breaches involved Social Security numbers, yet six of the nine covered entities warning of theft did not offer paid protection services to those affected--including two state agencies. Here is a look at some bad and good reactions to compromised data.  

  
## Advice Without Assistance

![](https://hdmpublishing.wpengine.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/11/p183tku8pa5mc16dt18thk541ul56.jpg)

The Indiana Family and Social Services Administration had a huge breach, affecting 187,533 clients whose protected information may have been disclosed to other clients following a programming error by a contractor. The agency advised all affected clients to place a fraud alert on their credit reports. Of the 187,533 clients, 3,926 may have had their Social Security numbers disclosed, according to a statement. This is being noted in the specific letters being sent to this smaller group. But rather than offer protection, the agency simply advised those with compromised SSNs to also place a security freeze on their credit reports, even though the breach began about three months before notifications were sent.

  
## Not PHI?

![](https://hdmpublishing.wpengine.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/11/p183tkuh6ova915hv1amqki21mlf7.jpg)

A contractor-operated server hosting the Michigan Cancer Consortium Web site was hacked and the Michigan Department of Community Health did not consider the compromised data to be protected health information under HIPAA. A spokesperson told the *Detroit News* that the information was not a medical record, but simply testing reports and the unit where the information originated is not a HIPAA-covered component of the department.  
  
PHI on the site included names, birth dates and Social Security numbers. While not notifying local media as HIPAA would require, the department determined compromised SSNs fell under the Identity Theft Protection Act and notified more than 49,000 individuals, the spokesperson told *Health Data Management*. The department did not offer protective services but advised placing fraud alerts with credit bureaus. A few days after being notified, an employee of WWJ Newsradio in Detroit reported a fraudulent effort was made to apply for a Kohls credit card in her name, but the application was denied.

  
## Decline to Disclose

![](https://hdmpublishing.wpengine.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/11/p183tkuofv1mk8iub1ois17h75t38.jpg)

San Jose Medical Supply in California notified current and former patients that their information was given to two rival vendors following the death of the owner. A new owner discovered the breach, which compromised patient names, dates of birth, Social Security numbers, home addresses, Medi-Cal numbers and clinical information. San Jose Medical Group advised affected individuals to place fraud alerts and monitor financial and insurance statements, but did not offer paid credit and/or ID theft protection services. The company initially declined to disclose the number of affected patients, but later reported to the HHS Office for Civil Rights that 800 were notified.

  
## Potential Trouble

![](https://hdmpublishing.wpengine.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/11/p183tkv1gl1f9d6fa1r3fgi117639.png)

North Texas Comprehensive Spine and Pain Center in Sherman notified nearly 3,000 patients of a potential information breach after an external hard drive was stolen, KTEN-TV, the local NBC affiliate reported. Information on the disk included names, birth dates, addresses, diagnoses and Social Security numbers. An employee responsible for the theft was fired. Patients were advised to place fraud alerts and monitor bank account statements. No protective services were offered.

  
## Tight-Lipped

![](https://hdmpublishing.wpengine.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/11/p183tkvbbr196uhi0sl96g5b97a.jpg)

A home health agency in St. Johnsbury, Vt., was particularly tight-lipped about a breach, declining to disclose the number of affected patients or compromised information beyond Social Security numbers. A nurse at Caledonia Home Health Care & Hospice on July 20 had a Netbook computer stolen from her home. The compliance officer for parent company Northern Counties Health Care told *Health Data Management* the decision was made to not talk to the media. The notification letter walked patients through how to protect themselves from identity theft and fraud, but protective services were not offered. More information is not yet available from the HHS Office for Civil Rights.

  
## Vulnerable Data

![](https://hdmpublishing.wpengine.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/11/p183tkvo871b7e3cm1fmi11equ8pb.jpg)

Olson & White Orthodontics in Florissant, Mo., in early September notified about 10,000 patients and their parents following the theft of two desktop computers and an external hard drive. Names, addresses, credit scores, Social Security numbers and e-mail addresses were compromised. The practice advised patients to protect themselves from fraud or theft but did not offer protective services, and an attorney for the practice declined to discuss reasons for not providing such services. The attorney did tell *Health Data Management* that computer equipment at the practice generally included encryption, but an investigation found vulnerabilities that could have resulted in storage of unencrypted data.

  
## Paying for Protection

![](https://hdmpublishing.wpengine.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/11/p183tl00n51uh8bpien672raec.jpg)

After its credit card processing firm was hacked, the Medical University of South Carolina in September notified approximately 7,000 patients. It seems the goal of the intrusion was to gain financial information which included names, billing addresses, credit card numbers and expiration dates, credit card authorization numbers and email addresses, according to a MUSC statement. The contractor, Blackhawk Consulting Group, is paying for one year of paid fraud protection services from Experian. Satisfied with Blackhawks response to the breach, MUSC has no immediate plans to terminate the contract, the school told the *Post & Courier* newspaper.

  
## A Little Help

![](https://hdmpublishing.wpengine.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/11/p183tl08pbm1o1hdhlra1n9e16l0d.jpg)

The Valparaiso (Ind.) Fire Department in August became at least the 36th fire unit to notify patients after billing firm Advanced Data Processing Inc. became aware in October 2012 that an employee was stealing names, dates of birth, Social Security numbers and other information to file fraudulent tax returns. But it was unaware that Valparaiso was affected until receiving notification in July 2013 from the Internal Revenue Service. The billing firm has identified several free identity protection support options for 860 affected patients and is offering professional services from ID Experts to those who believe additional security is necessary, according to a spokesperson.  

  
## Supporting Students

![](https://hdmpublishing.wpengine.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/11/p183tl0jh3tbu11hg1sd41mdms4ae.jpg)

The University of Mississippi Medical Center is offering paid identity theft protection services to 2,281 medical students after their protected information was inadvertently sent to 190 other students. The others were being informed via e-mail of health facilities that accept their student health insurance plan, but the emails included an attachment with a spreadsheet of information on the medical students. The mistake was quickly discovered and emails retracted, but 115 students had opened the e-mail and an unknown number also opened the attachment. Compromised information of medical students included name, date of birth, Social Security number, ethnic origin, address, insurance information, grade point average, credit hours earned, tuition and account balances.