> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://www.healthdatacon.io/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# 10 Ways to Make Encryption More Usable
- URL: https://www.healthdatacon.io/articles/10-ways-to-make-encryption-more-usable/
- Published: 2015-05-04T21:21:35.000Z
- Updated: 2026-11-10T10:52:22.000Z
- Description: Criminal hackings of protected health information show just how insecure PHI is, even two decades after the implementation date of the HIPAA Security Rule. The hacks are more maddening because one of the best defenses against them is encryption.
- Author: HDM Staff
- Tags: Cybersecurity

## 10 Ways to Make Encryption More Usable

Criminal hackings of protected health information show just how insecure PHI is, even two decades after the implementation date of the HIPAA Security Rule. The hacks are more maddening because one of the best defenses against them is encryption.  
  
Encryption is commonly used to protect PHI in transit or protect data on mobile computing devices. But it's not common to encrypt data that's "at rest"-residing in electronic health records systems, insurance membership databases and other information systems used almost constantly. That's because encryption slows processing systems-it takes time for encrypted data to be decrypted for a user, and then re-encrypted when that user is done with it. But there are solutions and more can be done. Industry experts offer 10 tips.

  
## Risk Management has Changed

![](https://hdmpublishing.wpengine.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/11/p19kgc6kg71kc5138v17b47ublk77.jpg)

Providers have traditionally not encrypted data at rest in databases, believing the risk of exposure was higher for data being transmitted. Also, many organizations are financially strapped, and they've tried to limit data protection expenses, says Linn Freedman, a privacy and security attorney at Robinson & Cole, a law firm in Providence, R.I. "Now, with significant cyber incidents, the healthcare industry is looking at this in a whole new light," she adds. "The risk management analysis has changed." (Photo: Fotolia)

  
## Still So-So Technology

![](https://hdmpublishing.wpengine.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/11/p19kgc70qh8611s5r1oe910o5bli8.jpg)

Encryption technology is better, more user-friendly and less expensive than it was five or 10 years ago, but it's still not perfect, says Doug Copley, IT executive and chief information security officer at eight-hospital Beaumont Health, based in Royal Oak, Mich. Encryption, he contends, is not always the best answer. "Implementing encryption adds complexity, which, in many cases, can slow access to information and cause clinicians a delay in patient care."  
  
However, there is no excuse for not encrypting laptops and other removable devices, Copley says. "If you're not encrypting every laptop in your environment, I would consider that negligence. It's easy to do and just a cost of doing business." (Photo: Fotolia)

  
## Encryption Leader

![](https://hdmpublishing.wpengine.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/11/p19kgc7gij1o471dq71bll1ghhjcc9.jpg)

Six-hospital Houston Methodist encrypts its inpatient and ambulatory EHRs. The organization considers encryption of data at rest to be a necessary safeguard and a cost of doing business, says Nick Desai, DPM, chief medical information officer.  
  
Log-on times for clinicians at Houston Methodist depend on the amount of data being pulled. It ranges from five to 10 seconds at the low end to 10 to 15 seconds on average, to the occasional 30 to 60 seconds, which he notes "isn't optimal." Single-sign-on technology mitigates the delays, and homegrown software enables clinicians to pause a session and continue it in another room or on another floor without having to sign back in. Houston Methodist is transitioning to an Epic EHR and is building a virtual private network to more quickly encrypt and decrypt data. (Photo: Fotolia)

  
## Productivity Loss

![](https://hdmpublishing.wpengine.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/11/p19kgc7udf1jsl1arq1l135d1n80a.jpg)

The extent to which encryption impedes data processing depends partly on the amount of data involved, says Jeremy Molnar, a vice president at CynergisTek, a health information technology security consultancy. That's because encryption works by coding a chunk of data at a time-so if the data can be easily broken down into fragments, the encryption process goes more quickly.  
  
Encryption is in wide use in other industries. The Payment Card Industry Security Standards Council requires encryption of Social Security numbers, except for the last four digits. Molnar wonders why the healthcare industry won't do the same. "There is no reason technology wise that you can't do this." He says performance issues are overblown as few stakeholders challenge the hypothesis and test encryption. Performance concerns stem from problems encountered a decade or two ago, when the technology was far less mature. Today, delays could range from microseconds to a minute or so, "but if you haven't tested, you don't have a rationale." (Photo: Fotolia)

  
## Take a Second Look

![](https://hdmpublishing.wpengine.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/11/p19kgc8fmkop01mnq1l8vicfdk2b.jpg)

As stakeholders look at encryption in a new light, Richard Blech, CEO of encryption vendor Secure Channels, suggests they consider this: "The reality is that there may well be no perpetually sustainable way to prevent intrusions, yet there is a way to perpetually prevent PHI theft. Securing data with the highest levels of encryption possible will render stolen data completely useless to the thief. With advanced and unhackable encryption, the hacker is left with a bunch of useless bits and bytes that can't be deciphered. The alternative is to continue to leave sensitive data readable and thus hackable, leaving organizations and their patients truly vulnerable." (Photo: Fotolia)

  
## No Secure Servers

![](https://hdmpublishing.wpengine.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/11/p19kgc90a930p5tt1p491tei14c8c.jpg)

"Secure" servers increasingly are under attack from the outside, because once a sophisticated hacker tricks an IT system user into providing valid credentials to access a server, the gates are open to the organization's data. With the Anthem hack, a systems administrator shared credentials that provided access to the organization's network. And credentials aren't even needed if vulnerable areas of a network are not patched and firewall rules are obsolete.  
  
The hacked Anthem data was stored in a secure environment, but it wasn't encrypted, the payer acknowledged. In a blog posted on the Ars Technica website for IT professionals in February, as the Anthem breach became public knowledge, Steven Bellovin, professor of computer science at Columbia University, noted that the most sensitive databases are always in use, so the data remains unencrypted. The same goes for most electronic health records. (Photo: Fotolia)

  
## Work with Vendors

![](https://hdmpublishing.wpengine.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/11/p19kgc9m2jgjvt4s1lajutumikd.jpg)

The use of database encryption generally requires some modification of the database schema to accommodate the encrypted data format, says Brian Evans a senior managing consultant at IBM. As a result, indexing and querying may be affected. But there are ways to ensure any performance hit is negligible, particularly for providers who have encryption embedded in their EHRs.  
  
Providers rarely work closely with their EHR vendors to find the happy medium between performance and protection that makes encryption feasible, Evans says. Providers should fully engage their vendor to help with enabling built-in encryption functionality or evaluating and implementing additional software that can ensure encryption and decryption processes are transparent to users. "It boils down to managerial fortitude to make it happen, and with the proper level of IT expertise."(Photo: Fotolia)

  
## Key Management is Key

![](https://hdmpublishing.wpengine.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/11/p19kgca3q21qh2hf2mfjsgi23re.jpg)

There are ways to speed access to the data, says Mark Hickman, COO at WinMagic, a vendor of full-disk encryption software. Having an encryption layer woven over an entire electronic file is what causes delays, he contends, but delays can be minimized with proper key management, which automatically unlocks files as authentication occurs. Single-sign-on technology also helps accelerate data access.  
  
Hickman offers this illustration: Think of key management as a key ring with keys that support role-based rules governing where a user can go and what the user can do in a network. Authentication is quicker when there are fewer user names and passwords to enter because you have keys that unlock the computer, hard drive and various files and folders. (Photo: Fotolia)

  
## Baby Steps

![](https://hdmpublishing.wpengine.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/11/p19kgcb0vephsm0t1pklc5h14btf.jpg)

Many stakeholders agree that encryption is the standard practice needed to ensure data security, and they are trying to move toward it, says Brad Rostolsky, a partner at the Reed Smith law firm. Some are starting by replacing unencrypted laptops coming out of service with encrypted ones.  
  
HIPAA requires healthcare covered entities to conduct regular comprehensive risk assessments; addressing vulnerabilities can be done over time, so projects remain economically feasible, he contends. But, he adds, the fear remains that if an organization encrypts its servers, usability will be hampered because the most important data is being accessed all the time. "With servers, there's a challenge to encrypting information that you need for the system to be usable." (Photo: Fotolia)

  
## The Bill

![](https://hdmpublishing.wpengine.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/11/p19kgcbf6r1c91vn49fb1kop1mspg.jpg)

Finally, the cost of encryption isn't that prohibitive, says Hickman of WinMagic. A 10-physician practice can expect to pay $1,200 to $1,300 for an encryption solution; a 200-bed community hospital faces a first-year cost of about $20,000, and about $4,000 a year afterward for support or upgrades. "For that size of hospital, that's not a lot of money," he says. (Photo: Fotolia)

  
![](https://hdmpublishing.wpengine.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/11/p19kgcbtin1chu3bs1p2h12ng1m2th.jpg)

The complete encryption feature story [is available here](https://www.healthdatacon.io/content/files/2026/11/organizations-consider-expanded-use-of-encryption-50432-1-3.html). (Photo: Fotolia)